CARAMEL BANANA PONCHE DE CREME

Ingredients

  • 6 medium ripe bananas

  • 2 tablespoons butter

  • 6 tablespoons sugar

  • 2 cups full-cream milk

  • 1 can (397 g) dulce de leche

  • 1 box (250 ml) evaporated milk

  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

  • 1 teaspoon salt

  • 3 dashes Angostura bitters

  • 1½ teaspoons vanilla extract

  • ½ teaspoon ground nutmeg

  • 1½ cups White Oak rum, Puncheon rum or alcohol of choice

Making the Dulce de Leche

For this recipe, I made my own dulce de leche using a can of sweetened condensed milk. Dulce de leche has a wonderfully rich caramelized milk flavour that works exceptionally well with the caramelized bananas.

For my original batch, I removed the label from the can of condensed milk, placed it in my slow cooker, covered it completely with water and cooked it on high for approximately eight hours.

The traditional stovetop alternative involves simmering the unopened can over low heat for approximately three hours, keeping it submerged beneath four to five inches of water.

Important safety note: Heating unopened cans can cause pressure to build up, potentially causing the cans to rupture. For home preparation, I recommend replenishing the water as necessary and allowing the dulce de leche to cool completely before using.

Instructions

Step 1: Caramelize the bananas

Peel the six ripe bananas.

In a saucepan over medium heat, add the bananas, sugar and butter.

Cook for approximately 5-10 minutes, stirring regularly and gradually mashing the bananas as they soften.

The bananas should be completely mashed, with a soft, thick, jam-like consistency and a beautiful golden-brown colour. This caramelization is essential to developing the flavour of our Ponche de Crème.

The darker you allow your caramelized bananas to become, the deeper the caramel flavor would be.

Step 2: Allow the bananas to cool

Remove the caramelized bananas from the heat and allow them to cool completely before proceeding.

Step 3: Blend the ingredients

Transfer the cooled caramelized bananas to a blender and add the full-cream milk, dulce de leche, evaporated milk, ground cinnamon, salt, Angostura bitters, vanilla extract and ground nutmeg.

Blend until completely smooth, rich and creamy.

Depending on the capacity of your blender, you may need to blend the ingredients in batches.

Step 4: Add the alcohol

Transfer the blended mixture to a large jug or mixing bowl.

Add the alcohol last and stir thoroughly until fully incorporated.

Step 5: Bottle and refrigerate

Transfer the Ponche de Crème into clean bottles, seal and refrigerate until thoroughly chilled.

The Ponche de Crème will thicken further as it chills, giving it a beautifully rich and creamy consistency.

Shake well before serving and enjoy!

Recipe Notes and Tips

Choosing your bananas: Use fully ripe bananas for their natural sweetness and developed flavour. Avoid overripe or mushy bananas or underripe bananas, as they will not provide the same sweetness or soft consistency when caramelized.

Don't rush the caramelization: The bananas should develop a golden-brown colour and become completely soft. Simply softening the bananas without caramelizing them will not produce the same depth of flavour.

Dulce de leche makes a difference: While regular sweetened condensed milk can be substituted, I highly recommend using dulce de leche for this particular recipe. It reinforces the caramel flavour and complements the caramelized bananas beautifully.

Be mindful of the spices: Resist the temptation to add additional cinnamon, nutmeg or bitters before tasting. The intention is to complement the caramel flavour, not overpower it.

Consistency: This is intended to be a thick, rich and creamy Ponche de Crème. Remember that it will thicken further once refrigerated.

Storage: Keep refrigerated at 4°C (40°F) or below and preferably consume within 3–4 days. Despite containing alcohol, this recipe contains fresh fruit and dairy and is not shelf-stable.

More Holiday Favourites

If you enjoy experimenting with different Ponche de Crème flavours, be sure to check out my Pumpkin Ponche de Crème recipe and look out for my updated version, as well as my Coconut Ponche de Crème, coming to YouTube this Christmas.

You can also explore my Holiday Favorites playlist on the YouTube channel for more delicious recipes to enjoy throughout the festive season.

Homemade Caramel Banana Ponche de Crème in glass bottles and a serving glass with ripe bananas and f
Homemade Caramel Banana Ponche de Crème in glass bottles and a serving glass with ripe bananas and f

Caramel Banana Ponche de Crème

Christmas is coming, and if there's one thing I'm committed to doing every year, it's creating a new, banging flavour of Ponche de Crème just for my Samsas!

Last year, I experimented with Coconut Ponche de Crème, which was an absolute banger. This year, I wanted to explore something completely different, and that's how this Caramel Banana Ponche de Crème came to life.

This recipe came straight from my imagination. I wanted something rich, thick, creamy and indulgent, with a beautiful caramel flavour that complemented the natural sweetness of ripe bananas.

The secret to this recipe is caramelizing the bananas before incorporating them into the Ponche de Crème. Cooking the bananas in butter and sugar until they develop a golden-brown colour and a soft, jam-like consistency brings out a deeper, richer flavour. When combined with the dulce de leche, these two ingredients complement each other beautifully.

I was particularly mindful of the spices and additional flavourings used in this recipe. While cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla and Angostura bitters are wonderful additions, we want to use them sparingly. It's very easy to overpower those delicate caramel notes, and the caramelized bananas and dulce de leche deserve to be the stars of this recipe.

This recipe yields a little more than two 750 ml bottles of Ponche de Crème. And that's perfectly fine because, after all, the chef needs to taste!

Homemade Caramel Banana Ponche de Crème in glass jar
Homemade Caramel Banana Ponche de Crème in glass jar

CONTACT THE SAVVY SAMSTER

Email: savvy@samanthastiell.com

SUPPORT ON PAYPAL

REPUBLIC BANK TT

ACCOUNT# 320033645731

@SamanthaStiell